EDD Audit Defense Attorney in San Diego for Employers

A letter from the EDD just asked for three years of payroll records, and the auditor wants to talk about the people you pay on a 1099. You are not sure what to hand over, what to say, or how large the bill could get.

Karin Backstrom is an EDD audit attorney who represents San Diego employers only. She reviews the letter and your contractor payments, prepares you for the auditor, and helps keep one audit from turning into wage claims.

Years defending employers
0 +
Employment cases litigated
0 +
Attorney on your matter
1

Request a Consultation

Tell Karin about your EDD audit.

Send the basics and we'll reach out to schedule your consultation.

Confidential. Reviewed personally by Karin Backstrom.

What an EDD Audit Reviews at a San Diego Business

The EDD audits employers to confirm that payroll taxes were reported and paid correctly and that workers were placed in the right category. An audit generally covers a three-year period, the 12 most recently completed calendar quarters. It usually starts with a test year, often the most recent full calendar year, and can expand to the full period or beyond it.

Most audits follow one of two tracks.

The auditor checks that the wages you reported were reported correctly and that state payroll taxes were paid and withheld. That covers Unemployment Insurance (UI) and Employment Training Tax (ETT), which the employer pays, plus State Disability Insurance (SDI) and California Personal Income Tax (PIT), which the employer withholds from wages.

The auditor looks at payments to people you treated as independent contractors and decides whether they were employees under California law. If they were, the EDD can assess the payroll taxes that should have been reported on those payments for the audit period.

Classification questions come up wherever a business pays people outside of payroll. In San Diego County that includes construction trades, salons and fitness studios, restaurants and hotels, delivery and logistics companies, staffing firms, and life science companies that work with consultants. Our guide to the EDD audit process for California employers explains the basics in more detail.

Why the EDD Picked Your Business

Some audits are routine. The EDD selects verification audits at random or by set criteria such as payroll size, number of workers, location, industry, and recent tax liability. A verification audit does not mean anyone suspects a problem.

Other audits have a specific cause. Common starting points include:

  • A benefit claim that does not match what you reported, often a former contractor who files for unemployment
  • A worker’s written request for a decision on whether they were an employee
  • Leads from the public or from inside the EDD
  • Compliance investigations, including on-site inspections with other agencies
  • Requests from other states

Knowing which kind of audit you face helps set the right approach for the first meeting.

How an EDD Audit Moves From Letter to Assessment

Each audit follows the same basic path. Here is what happens at each stage and where an employer has room to shape the result.

The EDD sends a notice with the date the auditor will come to your business or another location, a list of records, and a pre-audit questionnaire that should be returned within 14 calendar days. The EDD will try to schedule the audit at a convenient time, and you can have an attorney, enrolled agent, or accountant present or representing you.

The auditor explains the audit, asks how your business operates and keeps its books, and answers your questions. How your contractors are described here can frame the rest of the audit, so prepare the answers ahead of time.

The auditor tests your records and may talk with workers about questionable payments and working relationships. When classification is at issue, invoices, agreements, and proof that a contractor runs an independent business carry weight.

The auditor reviews the findings in person or by phone and tries to resolve disputes. If you disagree, you can ask for a pre-assessment conference with the auditor's supervisor.

If the EDD issues an assessment, the notice explains your petition rights and the deadline, so read it the day it arrives. A petition for reassessment goes to the California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board, and a hearing is held before an Administrative Law Judge.

What the Auditor Will Ask You For

California requires employers to keep payroll and worker records and to make them available to the EDD during business hours. Expect a request for most of the following.

  • Check registers, bank statements, and cash payment records
  • General ledger, journals, and annual financial statements
  • Payroll journals, individual earnings records, and Forms W-2, W-4, DE 4, 941, and 940
  • Quarterly state filings such as the DE 9 and DE 9C
  • Forms 1099 and your DE 542 independent contractor reports
  • Proof of ownership, such as your city business license or City of San Diego business tax certificate, CDTFA permit, and operating licenses
  • Invoices, written agreements, and corporate minutes when classification is in question

Gather the records before the entrance interview and review them with counsel first. Gaps and inconsistent explanations can lead the auditor to look beyond the test year.

Prepare for the auditor before the first meeting.

Karin reviews the audit letter, your contractor payments, and your records, then helps you decide what to provide and how to explain it.

How the EDD Decides Who Is an Employee

Since AB 5 took effect on January 1, 2020, California presumes a worker is an employee unless the hiring business shows all three parts of the ABC test.

  • A. The worker is free from your control and direction, under the contract and in practice.
  • B. The work is outside the usual course of your business.
  • C. The worker has an independently established business of the same type as the work performed.

Some occupations and business-to-business arrangements are judged under the older Borello test instead, which weighs control along with other factors. Certain licensed professionals fall under Borello without more, while other exceptions apply only when the business meets added requirements.

A signed independent contractor agreement does not decide the question. The auditor looks at how the work was actually done, the same facts that drive our San Diego misclassification defense work.

What an EDD Assessment Can Include

If the auditor finds unreported wages or misclassified workers, the assessment can stack several items for each quarter in the audit period.

  • Unemployment Insurance and Employment Training Tax on wages that should have been reported
  • SDI and Personal Income Tax withholding that was not taken from those payments
  • Penalties, including a 15% penalty for contributions not paid on time without good cause
  • Interest, which keeps running until the assessment is paid
  • DE 542 reporting penalties of $24 for each failure to report a contractor without good cause, or $490 if the failure was intentional

An audit can also end with no change, or with a credit if you overpaid. Preparing well helps make sure the final number reflects what actually happened.

Know where your contractor risk sits before the auditor asks.

Karin reviews the people you pay outside of payroll under the ABC test and the Borello test, and shows you which relationships an auditor is likely to question.

How Karin Handles EDD Audits for Employers

Karin represents employers only and handles each EDD matter herself, from the first letter forward. An EDD finding can also lead to wage claims, so she looks past the tax assessment from the start.

Karin reviews the audit notice, the period covered, and the questionnaire, and identifies whether you are facing a routine verification audit or one with a specific cause.

Each contractor relationship is tested under the ABC test or, where it applies, the Borello test, based on how the work was actually done.

She helps you organize the records, prepare for the entrance interview, and keep your explanations consistent with the documents.

If the findings are wrong or reach too far, Karin presents the facts and the law at the closing interview or a pre-assessment conference.

Workers treated as employees for tax purposes may also bring claims for overtime, missed meal and rest breaks, or unreimbursed expenses under Labor Code 2802, file a wage claim with the Labor Commissioner, or send a PAGA notice. Karin weighs that exposure alongside the audit, together with any wage and hour defense your business needs.

If some workers belong on payroll, Karin plans the change so it fixes future risk without creating new evidence for past claims, and updates the agreements that support the workers who remain contractors.

Why San Diego Employers Choose Backstrom Labor Law for EDD Audits

Owners want someone who understands both the payroll records and the employment law behind them.

Employment Law and Payroll Together

A classification finding is an employment law question as well as a tax question. Karin looks at both the assessment and the wage exposure behind it.

26+ Years Representing Employers

Karin began her career at Littler Mendelson and Sheppard Mullin, representing employers before agencies including the EDD, and has litigated more than 500 employment cases.

Employer-Only, With No Conflicts

The firm never represents workers. Its advice is built around keeping your business compliant and protected.

Local Counsel for San Diego Employers

Karin provides EDD audit defense for San Diego businesses, from Chula Vista to Escondido, and represents employers throughout California.

Trusted by Employers Across California

Karin is a talented and hard-working attorney who cares deeply for her clients. She is always there for us when we need her and she is fair with her rates. The partner we have received in her is invaluable - she helps support my staff in challenging situations and she keeps us compliant in the ever-changing CA laws. I am relieved of so much stress as a small business owner because of Karin at my side.

Carol Bender California Employer

Top-notch attorney, always accessible, fights hard for her clients.

Samaa Lada California Employer

Karin provided clear, strategic advice that helped us navigate a complex employment matter with confidence. From the initial consultation through resolution, she was responsive, thorough, and focused on protecting our business interests. Her ability to explain legal risks in practical terms made it easier for our leadership team to make informed decisions. We appreciated her proactive approach and strong litigation experience, which ultimately positioned us for a successful outcome. We would not hesitate to work with her again.

Benjema Hardi California Employer

Frequently Asked Questions About EDD Audits

It depends on what the auditor finds. A verification audit is a routine review and can end with no change. A classification finding is more serious, because the EDD can assess taxes, penalties, and interest on contractor payments across the audit period, and the same facts can support wage claims by the workers involved.

There is no fixed timeline. The audit starts with a test year and may expand to the full three-year period, or further, depending on what the records show. How quickly you produce organized records and answers affects the pace.

You are not required to have one. The EDD's Employer's Bill of Rights confirms you can have an attorney, enrolled agent, or accountant present or represent you. An attorney is most useful when contractor classification is at issue, because your answers can affect wage claims as well as taxes.

Paying the assessment does not count as admitting you owe it, and filing a petition for reassessment does not stop interest from accruing. Some employers pay and petition to limit interest. The right choice depends on the amount and the strength of the dispute.

The DE 542 is the EDD's Report of Independent Contractor(s). Businesses must file it within 20 days after paying an individual contractor $600 or more in a calendar year, or entering a contract for $600 or more, whichever comes first, when a federal 1099-NEC or 1099-MISC is required. The EDD explains the rules on its independent contractor reporting page.

Expect the auditor to start with that worker's relationship and then review others paid the same way. Gather that worker's agreement, invoices, and payment history, along with records for anyone in a similar role.

Yes. Karin represents employers throughout California, including businesses in Orange County, Riverside County, and elsewhere in the state.

Facing an EDD Audit? Get a Clear Answer.

Karin will review the audit letter and your contractor payments, explain where the risk sits, and help you prepare before the auditor arrives.